What Your Sexual Fantasies Say About You: A Gay Sex Therapist Explains

The mind is complex—and often mysterious. All of us have sexual fantasies. But sometimes, those fantasies surprise us. Many gay men find themselves wondering: Why am I fantasizing about something that doesn’t even make sense to me?

It’s a common experience. You may fantasize about something you wouldn’t actually want in real life—or imagine a sexual scenario with someone you’re not even attracted to. It can feel confusing, even shame-inducing.

So, what’s going on?

As a gay sex therapist, I work with clients every day who are trying to make sense of their erotic mind. One of the most important things I tell them is this: your fantasies are not random. They are clues—subtle signals from your subconscious mind that something deeper is at play.

In fact, many fantasies stem from our earliest emotional experiences, especially those involving shame, rejection, or unmet needs. As gay men, we are often exposed to messages that make us feel inadequate or "not man enough." These messages don’t just go away—they find new ways to resurface. One of the most powerful channels they use is fantasy.

Two Core Categories of Sexual Fantasy

From my experience as a gay sex therapist, most fantasies fall into two broad categories:

1. Expressing Something You Can’t in Real Life

Some fantasies allow you to symbolically get a need met—especially one you’ve been denied in your everyday life. For example, you might find yourself obsessed with the “perfect 10” guy: chiseled body, dominant energy, seemingly unattainable.

This doesn’t necessarily mean you want that person in real life. More often, it reflects a craving to feel special, desired, or noticed. For many gay men who grew up feeling invisible or rejected—especially by straight peers—this fantasy offers a symbolic reversal of that dynamic.

It’s no coincidence that much of gay porn centers on hypermasculinity or straight-identifying men. According to 2024 PornHub data, “straight guys” and “daddy” were among the top 4 most-searched categories by gay viewers. These categories tap into deeper psychological themes: power, authority, protection, or even forbidden attraction.

As a gay sex therapist, I encourage clients to reflect on what these fantasies allow them to feel—rather than judging the content at face value.

2. Re-Experiencing Something You Haven’t Resolved

Other fantasies are rooted in unresolved emotional wounds. For example, fantasies involving humiliation, degradation, or cuckolding may be tied to unprocessed guilt or shame.

This might sound counterintuitive, but the erotic mind often works in paradoxes. If you grew up feeling like you were a disappointment to your parents—or internalized shame for being gay—those unresolved emotions may get “eroticized” over time. In other words, the fantasy becomes a symbolic way to revisit and control the experience that once felt overwhelming.

Rather than being pathological, this is your mind’s creative (if imperfect) way of working through past pain.

Fantasy Is a Clue, Not a Prescription

The goal is not to act out every fantasy. Most gay men won’t—and shouldn’t—turn all their fantasies into reality. That’s not the point.

The point is to use your fantasies as tools for self-understanding. Ask yourself:

• What feeling does this fantasy give me access to?

• What emotional need might it be trying to fulfill?

• What parts of myself have I been told to reject, that this fantasy is reclaiming?

As a gay sex therapist, I’ve seen how healing it can be when someone learns to approach their fantasies with curiosity rather than shame. Too often, gay men have been taught to pathologize their sexuality—to see it as something broken, dirty, or dangerous. This leads them to suppress or ignore their fantasies, when in reality, those fantasies are a valuable source of insight.

The Erotic Mind Is a Mirror

Like dreams, sexual fantasies are windows into the unconscious. They may not reflect what you consciously want, but they do reveal what your psyche is grappling with. They highlight longings, fears, past wounds, and hidden desires.

So the next time a fantasy catches you off guard, pause before judging it. Get curious. Ask what it’s trying to tell you.

And if you find yourself overwhelmed or confused by what your fantasies bring up, don’t hesitate to reach out. Working with a gay sex therapist can help you unpack those deeper layers—without shame, and with compassion.

Because at the end of the day, your fantasies aren’t the problem. They’re part of the solution.

Gay Sex Therapist's Take

Need help making sense of your fantasies? Working with a gay sex therapist can help you reconnect with your body, desires, and emotional truth. Reach out today to start your journey toward deeper self-understanding. If you’d like to learn more about my practice, you can book a complementary consultation. You can also read more about my psychotherapy work with gay men.

Check out my Youtube Channel for more!

Book A Free Call